top of page
We're not accepting online orders yet. Please contact us to complete the order.
Pickup, ASAP (in 2 days)
"It's like BUTTAH!"
Cookies
The list of our amazing cookies! Some flavors are seasonal so please call to check availability ... Our Motto... "If it wasn't in our Grandmothers Kitchen it does not go into our products!"
This amazing buttery cookie is infused with Organic rosemary straight from the garden! This pack includes 25 scrumptious cookies, and its light sweetness can be enjoyed anytime! Perfect to compliment that morning cup of joe! 15.00 USD
The only cookie named after a male family member... Uncle Bud loved Potato Chips... This delicious shortbread cookie is packed full of potato chips and toasted pecans! It is that perfect mix of sweet and savory! Pack includes 6 12.00 USD
This Cookies is stuffed with Peanut Butter, Dutch Chocolate, is topped with Blackberry Preserves, and lightly dusted with powdered sugar! Pack includes 612.00 USD
We couldn't stop with only one kind of chocolate chip! This Creation is full of Semisweet, Milk, and Dark Chocolate Chips! Then we add walnuts and a sprinkling of chunky sea salt to finish off this Decadent Devilishly rich cookie! Created and named after Travis's chocolate loving Mom! Pack includes 612.00 USD
This Cookie is one of our favorites! It has a sugar cookie base with White Chocolate and Cranberries! We then roll it in our toasted sea salted almonds, and then we add a dusting of sugar! The salted almonds are just salty enough to cut the sweetness of the chocolate! Sweet and Savory Perfection! Pack includes 612.00 USD
This yummy Short Bread Cookie is rich with the nutty flavor of Brown Butter, and rolled in baking sugar! Do not be fooled by it's simplicity! It's flavor is sophisticated and the cookie seems to dissolve right on the tongue!12.00 USD
This classic soft chewy cookie is Fall in a bite! Packed full of Cinnamon, Ginger, Cloves, and Molasses this cookie could not represent the harvest season more completely! 12.00 USD
Aunt Ginger was famous for this take on a classic ginger snap cookie! Crisp and snappy on the outside, yummy and chewy on the inside, add the rich flavors of dark molasses, cinnamon and cloves, and we believe it is as perfect as a ginger snap can get! Of course Aunt Ginger was a favorite so we are a little biased...12.00 USD
0.00 USD
Pies and Hand Pies
Aunt Lizzie Always said; "There is not a problem to great, that can't be solved over a great piece of pie!"
This delicious little pie is packed full of Organic Granny Smith Apples, Cinnamon, and Butter... We start by cooking the apple filling and then we strain the juices... We take the juice and reduce it to the most amazing apple syrup... Its then reintroduced into the filling, and stuffed between a two divine Buttermilk Crusts... Topped with a sugar glaze and we believe its heaven in a bite! 8.00 USD
This classic Holiday Pie is the best Pumpkin Pie you will ever eat! You ask, How do I know this? ...Without success I searched for years for that perfect pumpkin pie recipe... One day I was telling Paul about my dilemma and he quickly shared his Grandma Lorreta's recipe. With the first bite of this incredible pie filling I knew my search was over. From that moment on it has become a holiday staple on my family table, and I hope it will become one of yours too. Add our Flaky Buttermilk Crust and you have a pie that you will never forget! 8.00 USD
This Organic Cherry Pie is a summer favorite! For this pie we find Organic Cherries that are at the peak of their sweetness , and pair it with our famous Buttermilk crust! 8.00 USD
This old school pie is a childhood favorite! My Nano use to pick the fresh rhubarb out of the garden and cook it down to the most amazingly balanced sweet/tart pie ever! We love using rhubarb and feel sad it has become an ingredient that is quickly being forgotten by the public... As long as we have anything to say about it, Buttah Boys is determined to keep this humble ingredient alive! Organic Rhubarb, Buttermilk Crust, and a sugar glaze. 8.00 USD
This heart shaped Organic Blackberry Hand Pie is the perfect way to say I love you! This Pie is filled with Aunt Esther's Blackberry filling... As a kid she would send me to pick the blackberries from her patch on the hill and it would take me forever to pick enough for her pie... I think it had something to do with me eating most of them before they made it into my pale! Organic Blackberries, Buttermilk Crust, and Sugar Glaze 8.00 USD
Is it a pie? Is it a Cake? Well we will let you decide! This awesome dessert has a top layer of Caramelized Sugar and Pecans... Then a layer of our Vodka Pie Crust... Then stuffed full of Organic Apple slices... Then another layer of crust! If heaven was a food this would be it! 7.00 USD
Cakes
Though vilified, we believe Marie Antoinette was right when she said; "Let them eat Cake!" One thing is for sure... A Buttah Boys Cake is worth loosing your head over!
This Amazing Bundt Cake has over a pound of Butter, two cups of Dutch Chocolate, a hint of Cinnamon, and then we Top it with a Chocolate pecan Frosting! You will never eat a more moist cake! It is a chocolate lovers dream! 45.00 USD
This incredibly moist white cake is flavored with our own Homemade vanilla, and is frosted with real buttercream... You won't find anything but real organic butter in our frosting! The filling is seedless Raspberry made from the best organic berries you can find! Prices determined on cake size needed so please call for a Quote... 0.00 USD
0.00 USD
40.00 USD
The most amazing Lemon Cake ever! We take organic Lemons and Rosemary and combine them in the most perfect way to create this light and airy cake. We add our Lemon Curd filling and top it off with our Lemon Buttercream! It is the Mediterranean in every bite! Price is for a 9" cake. Call for quote on other sizes.45.00 USD
Widget Didn’t Load
Check your internet and refresh this page.
If that doesn’t work, contact us.
bottom of page